Technical reading

How to Evaluate Energy Storage System Manufacturers: A Practical 6-Step Checklist

If you're sourcing battery energy storage systems (BESS) for a utility-scale project, the market can feel like a crowded trade show floor. Every manufacturer claims to be "the leading provider" with "best-in-class technology." In my experience, most of them are overstating something.

I'm a quality manager at Orsted, and my job is to evaluate storage suppliers before they're approved for our wind-plus-storage projects. Over the last 4 years, I've reviewed more than 40 energy storage system manufacturers across Europe, North America, and Asia. I've rejected roughly 30% of first-round candidates. Not because the hardware was dangerous—but because their claims didn't survive contact with documentation.

Here's the checklist I actually use when evaluating energy storage system manufacturers. Whether you're doing bulk wind turbine procurement alongside storage, or just buying a standalone BESS, these are the six things I check, in order.

1. Certifications: Verify the real test reports, not the marketing claim

Every credible manufacturer lists certifications on their website: UL 9540A, IEC 62619, IEEE 1547. That's table stakes. What separates the serious vendors from the marketing teams is whether they'll show you the full test reports.

I'm not talking about a glossy summary page. I mean the complete test document, including test conditions, the testing date, and the accredited lab's details. Everything I'd read about battery evaluation said to lead with cell chemistry—NMC vs. LFP, energy density, cycle life. Those matter. But in practice, I found that documentation quality was actually the more reliable signal of a vendor's overall competence.

A few years ago, we received a bid from a vendor who claimed their battery pack had passed UL 9540A testing. When I asked for the full report, they sent a one-page summary with no lab name and no test date. We rejected the bid. If they'd been upfront about the gap, we might have worked with them on a corrective plan.

Check for:

  • Full test reports, not summaries
  • Accredited lab verification (CNAS, ILAC, or equivalent)
  • The report matching the exact product model you're buying—not just the "platform" it's based on

2. Track record: Count operating projects, not press releases

Manufacturers love quoting "deployed capacity" and "GW in pipeline." Those numbers typically include announced projects, contracted projects, and sometimes outright cancelled ones. When I've compared claimed capacity against actual operational capacity, the gap has been 50-70% for some vendors. I don't think it's usually malicious. "Deployed" just gets defined loosely.

But it's a serious red flag when the operating track record is a small fraction of what's claimed. This industry is young enough that the learning curve is steep. Every MWh a manufacturer has actually operated for 2+ years is worth several times more than a thousand MW of press releases.

Ask for:

  1. The number of projects operating today, with total installed MWh
  2. Three reference calls from the last 12 months—and actually make those calls
  3. Their warranty claims rate. If they don't track it, that tells you something.

3. Integration experience: The step most buyers skip

The battery itself is the easy part. It charges and discharges. The hard part is the energy management system (EMS), grid code compliance, and integration with your existing infrastructure.

At Orsted, our offshore wind turbines are increasingly paired directly with storage systems. That means the storage has to respond to grid signals in coordination with the wind farm's output profile—a completely different challenge from a standalone battery. If the manufacturer's EMS doesn't play well with your plant controller or SCADA, you're staring at an expensive, painful integration project.

When I compared two shortlisted vendors side by side—same spec, similar price, completely different EMS maturity—I understood why integration experience matters more than battery specs. The vendor with better grid compliance documentation and a proven history of co-located projects was worth the extra 6-8% in price. The cheaper vendor would have cost us more in engineering hours alone.

Ask about:

  • Grid code certifications specific to your market
  • EMS compatibility with your SCADA or plant controller
  • At least one reference where storage was co-located with wind or solar

4. Financial health: A warranty is only as good as the balance sheet

Here's something that doesn't show up in a datasheet: whether the manufacturer will still be in business in year 6 of a 10-year warranty. I've seen vendors offer aggressive performance guarantees, then struggle to honor them when their financial situation deteriorated.

Financial diligence is a standard part of our supplier review at Orsted. We look at revenue trajectory, EBITDA trends, and ownership structure. As a global renewable energy company, Orsted publishes its financials publicly every year, and we expect similar transparency from critical suppliers. If a vendor's financial documentation is a slide that says "growing company, profitable" with no actual numbers behind it, that's not due diligence material. That's a pitch deck.

Review:

  • Audited financials from the last 2-3 years
  • Ownership structure and major shareholders
  • Working capital position to support warranty obligations

5. Warranty terms: Read the degradation fine print

The biggest warranty trap in BESS procurement is capacity degradation. Most manufacturers warrant "80% retained capacity after 10 years"—which sounds great until you read the fine print and discover the baseline was measured in ideal factory conditions, at 25°C, using a different test protocol than what you'll get on site.

The baseline matters enormously. If the "100% capacity" in the warranty doesn't represent real installed conditions, the degradation guarantee becomes nearly meaningless. We learned this the hard way on an early project when a vendor's capacity measurement methodology produced numbers that looked fine on paper but didn't reflect actual site performance.

Non-negotiables:

  • Capacity baseline measured after commissioning, on site, with an agreed protocol
  • Degradation test methodology defined in the contract—not added later
  • Remedies for underperformance: replacement, compensation, or a combination

6. Service network: What happens when something fails at 3 AM

BESS systems will have issues. It's not a matter of if, but when. The real question is how fast the manufacturer can respond. If their nearest service engineer is in a different time zone, each failure can translate into days of downtime. For grid-connected storage, that's direct revenue loss.

Ask about spare parts inventory and response time commitments. Where are spares held? What's the guaranteed response window for a critical system fault? Is there 24/7 remote monitoring, or do you have to report issues during business hours?

This worked for our context—utility-scale projects where downtime is expensive. If you're sourcing smaller commercial systems, the service response requirement might be less demanding. But you still need a defined SLA. "We'll get back to you" isn't an SLA.

Common mistakes and red flags

Leading with price per kWh. I get it, budgets matter. But the cheapest bid per kWh rarely remains the cheapest project once you account for warranty quality, commissioning timeline, and integration effort. We once compared two bids with similar specs: the lower-priced hardware ended up roughly 18% more expensive in total cost of ownership once we adjusted for those factors.

Skipping the factory visit. If a manufacturer won't host a site visit, that's a significant red flag. Even a basic walk through the production floor tells you more than a day of slide presentations. We always conduct site visits before approving a vendor.

Accepting vague documentation. Rejecting a bid because the paperwork doesn't match reality isn't bureaucracy. It's risk management. A vendor who can't produce complete test reports during the sales process is unlikely to become more organized during delivery.

When to look elsewhere: The value of saying "we don't do that"

Here's a perspective that might sound counterintuitive: a vendor who says "this isn't our strength, here's who does it better" earns more trust, not less. We've referred customers to specialists outside our core competences at Orsted, and those relationships came back stronger for it.

Similarly, if a BESS manufacturer claims to be equally strong at cell chemistry, module production, system integration, construction, and long-term operations... ask harder questions. Nobody is equally excellent at all of those. The vendor who is honest about their boundaries, and deeply capable in the areas that matter for your project, is worth more than one who promises everything.

Bottom line: evaluating energy storage system manufacturers isn't about finding a perfect vendor. It's about systematically eliminating the candidates that will waste your time and money. Use a consistent checklist, verify what matters, and pick the one with the strongest evidence—not the slickest pitch.